From Itatí Cantoral to Juan Gabriel: Here are the Most Controversial Mañanitas to the Virgin of Guadalupe

December has arrived, bringing with it the long-awaited Mañanitas to the Virgin of Guadalupe. This cherished celebration unites devotees and features special performances by artists who sing in her honor before the sacred altar. The tradition began in 1955 and is held annually on December 12, the holiday of Mexico's patron saint.

Over the years, countless artists, including Lucero, El Buki, Emmanuel, and Mijares, have taken the stage at the Basilica of Guadalupe to pay tribute to one of the most revered religious figures in Mexico.

However, despite the solemnity of the event, controversies have occasionally overshadowed this celebration. From performances that sparked ridicule to interventions by the Vatican itself, here are some of the most controversial moments from the Mañanitas over the years.

Juan Gabriel and his dance moves

When it comes to icons of Mexican and Latin American music, Juan Gabriel is always front and center. Known for his unmatched talent, vocal prowess, and signature stage presence, his 1999 Mañanitas performance became a flashpoint for controversy.

Standing before the Virgin's altar, the 'Divo de Juárez' performed 'La mujer que yo amo.' Everything seemed normal at first as mariachis accompanied him. However, things took a turn when the singer began to dance along to the music. While his movements were characteristic of his vibrant persona, many perceived them as disrespectful in the solemn setting.

Itatí Cantoral's memorable performance

If you've spent enough time on the internet, you might recognize actress Itatí Cantoral—famous for her role as Soraya Montenegro in 'María la del Barrio'—as the star of one of the most talked-about Mañanitas performances online.

Cantoral was invited in 2016 to sing 'La Guadalupana,' one of the most emblematic songs dedicated to the Virgin. Overcome with emotion, her rendition was filled with dramatic flair, resulting in a performance that quickly went viral. The clip became one of the most popular memes in Latin America, cementing her place in internet folklore.

Alexander Acha's unconventional rap

Alexander Acha, son of legendary singer Emmanuel, also faced criticism after his unique participation in the 2020 Mañanitas. Selected to honor the Virgin, Acha surprised audiences by performing a rap song of his.

While his performance was heartfelt, many devout attendees found it inappropriate for the occasion, sparking widespread disapproval among traditionalists.

Vicente Fernández and the Vatican Ban

Although Vicente Fernández never performed at the Virgin's altar, a curious anecdote surrounds the legendary mariachi singer. Known for his deep devotion to the Virgin of Guadalupe, it's said that in his early years, Fernández would visit the temple in Huentitán el Alto, his hometown, every December 12 to serenade the Virgin.

As Fernández's fame grew, so did the crowds at the temple. Allegedly, the Vatican expressed concern that the singer's presence was overshadowing the Virgin, leading to an informal ban on his participation in future celebrations.

Ángela Aguilar's rejection

Finally, a more recent controversy surrounds preparations for the 2024 Mañanitas. According to various entertainment sources, Televisa had invited Ángela Aguilar to perform at this year's event, while TV Azteca reportedly considered featuring Argentine singer Cazzu.

However, Ángela Aguilar ultimately declined the invitation. Many speculate that her decision stemmed from the backlash she faced after making her relationship with Christian Nodal public.